The Clean and Green Club, December 2025

<!doctype html>

 

Having trouble reading this as an email? Please visit thecleanandgreenclub.com to read it comfortably online.

Shel Horowitz’s Clean and Green Marketing Tip: December 2025

Great news! All of my eBooks with a publication date through 2023 are now free to subscribers to The Clean and Green Club (the monthly newsletter I’ve been publishing in some form all the way back to 1997).
Volunteer for Fishbowls
People making protest posters
Image: Andrea Piacquadio via Pexels 

I regularly attend several networking meetings over Zoom. At the UK-based Networking for Good one recent Monday, the first great thing that happened was a first-time attender, a video expert, giving us all permission not to obsess over ums and uhs when we speak or make a video. I’ve never liked the Toastmasters focus on that, and it’s one reason why I never joined. It’s a sign that we’re human, and even super-experienced professional speakers have them slip in.


Even better, they asked for a volunteer to have people ask anything they wanted about the volunteer’s business, and I eagerly waved my hand. And I’d urge you to wave your hand wildly when you’re offered a chance to be in a fishbowl, because there are so many benefits.


Yes, I recognize that many people are uncomfortable bringing attention to themselves or speaking to a group. While public speaking or going on TV is not scary for me (anymore), I frequently do things that
are out of my comfort zone. It’s one of the ways I continue to grow and learn. Two days before that meeting, I asked the protester standing next to me who was wearing a slogan that disturbed me deeply if he was open to discussing it. That was definitely out of my comfort zone, but we had a five-minute conversation where we disagreed but were both respectful and each brought some facts. So put your hand up anyway.

It won’t be as scary as that ?


To name a few, it’s:

  1. An opportunity to get consulting at no charge, as people brainstorm together to help you solve a problem
  2. A chance to see how others think, and figure out who in the group you might hire to go deeper on solving that problem (I’ve gotten many clients because people saw the value of advice I was giving without even charging)
  3. A fabulous way to let people know more about what you do without getting accused of being too salesy
  4. A chance to show off your problem-solving abilities to others, as I did here
  5. A market research bonanza, because you have no idea of what questions you’ll br asked—and those questions provide deep insight into the minds of your prospects
  6. And, of course, the challenge of spontaneously answering keeps your mind sharp and builds skills useful when you’re pitching clients, being interviewed in the media, or even being grilled by a government body with authority to grant or decline your permit. Plus, it’s fun.

I also think the session is worth sharing with you, because it shows a lot about how I see the world, and how I find possibilities to put it together differently—and also how I seized the opportunity to clear up misunderstandings (such as the ideas people had that my strategies were specific to my own country or were only relevant to large corporations. Actually, large corporations usually have in-house experts, and my client load is almost entirely micro-sized businesses and community groups.) You’ll also see my techniques for replying under pressure—such as when I began my answer with “Mm-hmm. Great question” or related my reaction when I was asked about what to do for a pizza shop. Those little fillers bought me the 5 or 10 seconds I needed to decide which case studies I would talk about or what solution I would offer that pizza shop.

Yeah, and I took that guy’s advice about leaving in most of the ums and uhs, which I do think adds a layer of authenticity ;-). Here’s the transcript, edited to remove names, clean up punctuation, etc.:


Q: How applicable are your methods beyond the lower 48?

A: Oh, totally. I’ve gotten clients in Australia, all across Asia and Europe, um, occasionally in Latin America. Basically, certain things don’t work, like if I’m talking about whatever government subsidies might be available, that’s not going to be relevant, but I almost never talk about that. It’s not my expertise, and I’m much more interested in the fundamental concepts. That, for example, when you build environmental and social good into your business, you are then able to project yourself as something different and better than your competitors. My favorite example is ice cream: Haagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry’s are both worldwide companies. One is cold and corporate, I call it the Exxon of ice cream. And the other is warm and fuzzy, uh, with old bearded people on the labels, like me. And it has big commitments to social justice, to employing the so-called unemployable, to green energy. Which one are you going to take your $6 or your £4, um, and buy at the supermarket? It’s a very easy choice. The ice cream isn’t that different. So, you get more customers, you get less resistance from those customers, you might be able to charge a little more, will probably have better relationships with your neighbors, your competitors even, and yes, your government regulators who are in charge of you. So, my question is, why wouldn’t any company want to build this in?

Q: Oh, I was going to say, ask Shel what he wants, because I know he’s bringing a book out. So, this time next year, where do you want to be?
A: I want to have written the book, um, which means that I will have found a charity partner, and then found a publisher. The book is about being an activist when you’re old. And, so I—it takes me usually about 6 months to a year to write a book, so I hope to have it done and be into the marketing phase as the publisher is readying it for publication, which is also something that can take a year. I’m not self-publishing, and therefore I’m on somebody else’s timetable when I do it. But, uh, because it’s a relevant book right now in this country, I suspect they may put it on fast track. And my grandson will be 4 instead of 3, and I expect that he will still be delightful. That’s kind of what I want to be. And oh, yeah, I also want to be living in a democracy again by then, which involves not just me, but millions of other people to make that happen.

FOLLOW-UP Q: Well, by this time next year?

A: Yeah, why not? Just because his term won’t be over doesn’t mean that he has to have the power that we’ve given him. What has been given can be taken back. So he might still be president, but he might be unable to pass anything through Congress, for example, because all he needs is about 5 of his Republican buddies to jump ship, and he doesn’t have anybody to vote him anything anymore. It’s a very, very tight Senate and House.

Q: Shel, how does it apply to small… Um, interpret what they’re about. Like, small practice like mine?

A: Well, I’m a small practice like yours. I am a one-person business. I’ve never had an employee in 45 years in business, I have freelancers, and um, partners for various things, but I am as small as it’s possible to get. I don’t even have a separate office. I work out of my home. And these principles were adopted from my own career, so they are all extremely applicable. So, as, uh, going way, way back, about differentiation, when I started really focusing on resumes, which was 1984 or 85. I put a little ad in the Yellow Pages, a half-inch ad, that said, Affordable Professional Resumes While You Wait. Nobody else had a slogan like that. I started getting lots of clients. Just that simple a thing. It was, I don’t know, $50 a month or something like that to have that in. And back in those days, before everybody had their resumes written by an AI bot, it was very effective. And when I moved into business-to-business services, I was able to connect on various online communities that gave me as much reach within those communities as any big corporation would have. So, and then as I began to differentiate as the green and social conscious marketer, the people who were attracted to that would find me.

Q: And what’s your recommendation for the most effective marketing tool currently that you’ve…?

A: Well, it’s bespoke, so it’s going to depend on who you are and what you do, and what your interests are. Like, for example, I’ve got a client now whose socially conscious book should be coming out next year, finally. And, um, she is not a good candidate for radio and TV, because she’s a double-stroke survivor, she speaks slowly, and she thinks slowly. So normally that’s a great medium for somebody with a book like hers. It’s not going to work for her, I’m not going to suggest it. Uh, for her, we’re going to be courting print interviews. And her goal is not to sell a huge number of copies, and there’s also going to be some word of mouth in the communities where they believe in what she’s writing about. And it’s going to be very targeted and very cheap, actually, and paid advertising will not be a part of it. It almost never is for my clients. It’s the last thing I suggest in very few situations.

Q: So, Shel, what are some tangible impacts your business have done, maybe through your clients? Because I’m interested… because you have this, uh, amazing message to make, like, the world a better place. Um, are there any specific, kind of, examples of how you’ve made an impact?
A: Mm-hmm. Great question. So, I’ll just talk about some of the clients I’ve worked with. I had a guy who came to me with, uh, he owns a conference center, and it happens that 2 or 3 owners ago, that property was the birthplace of the safe energy movement in the United States. So I wrote him a marketing plan about attracting the kinds of events for whom the organizers would find themselves walking on sacred ground coming there. Like, you can be where in… not in the room where it’s happening, but in the room where it happened, 50 years ago, these were where these meetings were held. This is the commune where so many of the experts in the safe energy movement happened to be living at that time. And, um, I don’t think he would have ever thought of doing that on his own.

I had another client who has a cell phone sized solar lamp. And with her, I brainstormed a huge list of applications for it, ranging from disaster relief to night lights for kids. And, um, so I think I expanded her horizons about what’s possible.


And my favorite example is actually not a real client, but a radio interviewer once asked me, “well, this is all well and good for big corporations. What would you do for a pizza shop owner?” So, I said, hmm, nobody’s ever asked me that before, and on the spot, I came up with this idea that the pizza shop owner could go into a local inner-city low-income high school, recruit a few kids, teach them how to grow tomatoes and garlic and oregano, teach them how to make a pizza, and then teach them how to go into their schools on a Friday and say, okay, we’re taking orders for Monday delivery. Monday, in the U.S., is a dead day in the restaurant industry. Nobody goes out to eat, most restaurants are closed. So, this pizza shop owner is going to open on Mondays, make the exact number of pizzas that’s already ordered and prepaid. The kids are going to deliver them to their classmates and collect a little bit of the money. And basically, there are no losers in this except the school cafeteria…Yeah, and that was just on the fly that I came up with that.


Q: What are you the best at?

A: I think I’m really good at seeing the way things fit together in ways that other people don’t fit together, and how you can form partnerships, and how you can really just shift your thinking, like that pizza shop example. Um, that’s—I could immediately see the connection between making pizzas and helping low-income kids, uh, both with entrepreneurial skills and also with getting better food into their bellies. I think I’m really good at that, and I’m also a pretty darn good writer and communicator. I invented what I call the story behind the story press release, which is not the Who, What, Where, When, Why press release that we’re all taught to write. Uh, so instead of “electronic privacy expert releases new book,” when I had a client with a book on electronic privacy, my headline was, “It’s 10 o’clock. Do you know where your credit history is?” Yeah, so just reframing the whole thing, I’m very good at that. Where I’m lousy at is managing all the little details of a big project.

Discover why Chicken Soup’s Jack Canfield, futurist Seth Godin, and many others recommend Shel’s 10th book, Guerrilla Marketing to Heal the World (and download a free sampler). Autographed and inscribed copies available.
Marketer of the Day Interview
Robert Plank just released the interview he did with me for his Marketer of the Day podcast. We covered a lot of ground in just 30 minutes. A few of the highlights (you can read more in the extended summary on my interviews page):

  • One simple action any consumer of chocolate can do to better the world
  • How a very NON-tree-hugger company (you know their name) doubled the market for organic foods and personal care products by going way beyond the Whole Foods customer profile
  • The kind of lateral thinking I bring to my clients that creates value and opportunity by seeing possibilities that aren’t obvious but make perfect sense
  • Why I love engineers, with three examples of how they change the world
  • How to harness the savings from “low-hanging fruit” changes to create capital and momentum to take the next steps
  • Community-focused and eco-centric alternatives to Amazon and Google

https://www.robertplank.com/1476-guerrilla-marketing-heal-world-shel-horowitz/

Movie Reviews and More Podcast
We didn’t talk about movies, but Brian Sebastian interviewed me about activism on his Movie Reviews and More podcast. In just over 20 minutes, we discussed:
  • How activism in my teens turned me into a marketer (1:13)
  • How, in my 40s, starting the campaign that saved a mountain (1:30) led me back to the business world, with a new focus on profiting through environmental and social good (2:24)—and why, now, I’m swinging back to writing a how-to book for badass older activists (3:59)
  • How sometimes you find out what impact you had—but even when you don’t, you still have impact (6:10)
  • The lessons in humility I learned from Pete Seeger (8:34)
  • Who will inherit the Earth if we humans don’t get our act together (10:02)
  • Lessons I learned from my mom about confronting injustice even in your own family, and finding non-obvious ways to make a difference (10:12)—and from my dad about living your truth even when the world tells you differently (11:01)
  • How Trumpism may create opportunities for true progressive alternatives well beyond the centrism of mainstream Democrats—and how few people it can take to set deep change in motion (12:42)
  • How ordinary people have made big societal changes, over and over again—and why, more than ever before, we need to mobilize in opposition NOW (16:21)
  • The little thing I’ve done on Facebook for more than 2800 days in a row that empowers others and strengthens community (19:32)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0BAJUcr-1cw 

East Trade Winds Networking Group
I’ll be giving a short 15-minute presentation in environmental and social good as a profit strategy for the East Trade Winds networking group on Tuesday, February 10, some time between 8-9 a.m. Eastern (5-6 a.m. PT). It’s free to register for the weekly calls; here’s the link.

View highlights from (and listen to) more than 30 podcasts ranging from 5 minutes to a full hour. Click here to see descriptions and replay links.

From Ellen Finkelstein:

A couple of friends have been frustrated by not seeing progressive politicians or well-known thought leaders offer positive ideas for improving life in the United States. So we decided to create a place for anyone to post ideas on a variety of topics, such as gun violence, healthcare, homelessness, poverty, immigration, and more. And we hope people who can implement them will notice. It’s a simple site but it works.

Please post your ideas here and then share the site! https://www.project2029.community

Revenge of the Tipping Point

Hands Across the Hills

Revenge of the Tipping Point
By: Malcolm Gladwell (Little, Brown and Company, 2024)

After reading at least three of his earlier books, I’m always impressed by Gladwell’s lateral thinking. Not uncritically; I’ve often found at least one set of conclusions that don’t match my reality—and I found one here, which I’ll bring up later. But he has a way of shaking up the mainstream view of the world with fresh thinking.


Maybe the best example is
David and Goliath, which I reviewed in April. Even in my four years as a yeshiva (Jewish day school) student, David was always presented as the extreme underdog, a young shepherd who risked all to challenge a bully. But as Gladwell convincingly argues, David was an elite fighter using the most powerful weapon of his day. Once he set the rules of engagement to play to his strengths and not the giant’s, he had pretty much already won.

But let’s get back to THIS book. A lot of what he covers is rooted in the idea that averages are often meaningless; it’s much more useful to look at what’s happening on the edges, the extremes. He begins and ends with the Sackler family, owners of Purdue Pharma, the manufacturer of OxyContin—the drug that turned opiate addiction into an epidemic with some 80,000 fatalities. Gladwell compares rates of overdoses by state and notices a pattern: states that required triplicate recording (and filing a copy with the state) of opiate prescriptions had far lower death rates than those that didn’t. While annoying to doctors, this simple rule meant that doctors were under state scrutiny and greatly decreased the incidence of frivolous opiate prescriptions. Thus, despite its much higher population, Illinois was far less hard-hit per capita than neighboring Indiana, which didn’t have that requirement (p. 266).


Purdue, under the advice of its well-paid consultants from McKinsey (pp. 285-291), quickly learned not even to bother with the triplicate states. Instead, they shifted their marketing to focus on those doctors already prescribing opiates much more often than most docs. Essentially, they were using the Pareto Principle (a.k.a. the 80/20 rule) to sift out the easiest doctors to woo—and, astoundingly, that fed a system where one percent of doctors wrote 49 percent of the opioid prescriptions, with “superspreader” docs prescribing them up to 1200 times more often (p. 294). For more on Pareto, please see
my review of Perry Marshall’s 80/20 Sales and Marketing (scroll down).

Opioids are only one paradigm in this book. Others include bank robberies, Medicare fraud in Miami, an elite public high school that developed a major suicide problem, a housing development that enforced racial integration through rigid quotas similar to those often used to keep people of color out, the shocking racist reasons why elite universities including Harvard have varsity programs in obscure sports like women’s rugby, an early (and famous) COVID superspreader event at a biotech conference in Boston, public awareness of the Holocaust, and the massive public shift on same-sex marriage and general acceptance of the LGB community (I’m deliberately not including the TQ we often see at the end, because it’s not clear to me that the same level of acceptance covers trans folks).


I don’t have space to discuss all of those, but let me touch on the last two.


Gladwell says the Holocaust jumped into mass consciousness quite late, following a 1978 TV series watched by about half the people in the US. He says that until 1984, the US had only ONE Holocaust museum, founded in Los Angeles in 1961, more than 15 years after the end of the war (p. 209). He cites several popular history textbooks by the likes of H. Stuart Hughes and the collaborations by Henry Steele Commager and Samuel Eliot Morison that gave the Holocaust just a few lines (p. 211).


True, many survivors didn’t want to talk about their experience, even with their children and grandchildren. But for me, growing up in heavily Jewish New York City in the 1960s and 70s, the Holocaust was omnipresent. We all knew someone whose parents or grandparents or aunts or uncles were survivors, and who had other relatives who were killed. As a grade-schooler, my wife (my age, also raised Jewish in NYC) played a schoolyard game called “Concentration Camp.” I had a good friend whose parents fled Eastern Europe for Cuba—and fled again to the US when Castro came to power. And I remember, long after I left yeshiva, watching a horrific film about the Holocaust, shown in my public high school, which I graduated from in 1973, five years before that TV series.


Also, Elie Wiesel published his first Holocaust memoir in 1955 and Anne Frank’s diary was published in 1947. These books sold quite a few copies. So my questions for Gladwell are 1) Why if this was so deeply ingrained in my subculture experience did it apparently make no impression on the wider culture “overstory” until the “miracle” of a just-three-networks TV culture made it possible to reach an entire country at once and made the Holocaust part of the everyday narrative and something to study? 2) Where are the blind spots in HIS research that made it look like interest in the Holocaust came up out of nowhere after that TV series?


One insight Gladwell shares about many tipping points is that even just before the tipping point is reached, change may seem relegated to the distant future. Just months before victory Lenin didn’t think he’d live to see the revolution (p. 236). Vaclav Havel saw Gorbachev’s visit to Prague not as the capitulation it was, but as the oppressor checking n on his colony (p. 235). So too with the incredible shift in LGB acceptance. As recently as 2004, George W. Bush was calling for a constitutional amendment to prohibit same-sex marriage nationally, and many conservative states adopted restrictions. But 2004 was also the year the Massachusetts Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage in the state. Just 11 years later, the US Supreme Court, in
Obergefell v. Hodges, made it legal throughout the country.


For Gladwell, 25 percent is often the tipping point (p. 127, p. 255). Forces for change accumulate very slowly until that magic quarter, or sometimes magic third (pp. 121-124), is reached. And then society seems to change instantly—but years of work have gone into that “instant” transformation. I attended my first same-sex wedding ceremony (not a legal marriage back then, obviously) around 1979, more than 20 years before it became legal in Massachusetts and 35 before
Obergefell.


Despite its occasional flawed time frames, this book is definitely worth your time. The university athletics section alone should be required reading for any class on civil rights, racial justice, or academic elitism.

Connect with Shel

Turn Your Sustainability/CSR Report Into Powerful Marketing!  http://goingbeyondsustainability.com/turn-that-nobody-reads-it-csr-report-into-a-marketing-win/

About Shel

Speaker, author, and consultant Shel Horowitz of GoingBeyondSustainabiity.com helps businesses find the sweet spot at the intersections of profitability with environmental and social good — creating and marketing profitable products and services that make a direct difference on problems like hunger, poverty, war, and catastrophic climate change. His 10th book is Guerrilla Marketing to Heal the World.

If you’re not already a subscriber, please visit http://goingbeyondsustainability.com and scroll to the very bottom left corner. You’ll find lots of interesting information on your way to the subscription form, too.

————–

Links in this newsletter may earn commissions. Please click here for our privacy and endorsement policy.

 

Powered by:

GetResponse

Leave a Comment

Name: (Required)

E-mail: (Required)

Website:

Comment: